Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers, Inc.

Fort Wayne, IN 46809
Company Memberships
Message Company

About Us

Over our many years in business we have consistently applied our own values and beliefs in all that we do. We exercise great care in the hiring and training of our employees. We continuously obtain and maintain professional certifications and licenses. We invest in the highest levels of technologies. We treat everyone with consideration and respect. We are careful and efficient, and we pay attention to details. We strive to advise our clients to do what’s best for them after hearing our knowledgeable view of their options.

We are proud of the results we achieve for our clients. We know that when we’ve done right by them, they will come back and refer us to others. Please read our Testimonials to see for yourself what people experience when they work with us.

Here’s a quick overview of what we do. There’s detailed information throughout our site, and we invite you to take a closer look at all our capabilities.

Personal Property Auctions


  • We’re certified and experienced in estimating the value of your personal property.

Antiques, Art and Personal Property

  • We know how to get great results for you, no matter what you wish to sell.

International Online Auctions

  • We’re the market leader in getting the world to your auction.

Consignment Auctions

  • We hold well-attended, periodic consignment auctions in our gallery.

Real Estate Auctions


  • We sell everything from million dollar properties to fixer-uppers.


  • We specialize in lake properties in Indiana and Michigan.


  • We know how to parcel farm properties for the best outcomes.


  • Your building deserves our highly-refined, targeted marketing approach.

Senior Relocation

Packing & Moving

  • Our white glove care has earned us rave reviews by our pickiest clients.

Selling your home and personal property

  • After we get you moved, we can complete the sale of your home and property within 30 - 45 days.


  • If your belongings won’t all fit into your new place, we can help you store the rest.


  • If some of your keepsakes will go to out-of-town family members, we can handle getting them there, intact.

Real Estate Sales

Traditional Listings

  • We’re licensed to sell real estate in whichever way makes sense to you, after hearing a detailed description of your options.


  • If you think it’s risky to auction your home, you owe it to yourself to hear what our experience has taught us.

Company Timeline


Company History

1998 – Developed Senior Relocations Services

2001 – Founded and incorporated “McCulloch Systems, Inc.”

It'll be sunny (we hope)! Temp 2215.

2006 – Founded and incorporated “Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers, Inc.”

2007 – Founded Scheerer McCulloch Waterfront Company

2012 – Implemented simultaneous, international & local live, online bidding 

2012 – Implemented wireless & computerized clerking, cashiering, barcode registration

2014 – Remodeled auction gallery to enhance security, promote live online bidding, & offer comfort/ convenience to live audience bidders

2015 – Implemented cloud-based, client-interactive project management available to each client

2015 –  Added a new, professionally designed website

2018 – Installed the Watchfire digital front sign to give our clients maximum advertising to over 35,000 vehicles daily

2018 – Opened second auction gallery at our Ardmore location to allow multiple same-day auctions

2022 – Senior Relocations Services has moved over 4,000 seniors/families

2022 – Opened second location Senior Relocations Services serving Indianapolis and surrounding areas

2023 – Implemented Salesforce, cloud-based software designed to help businesses connect to their customers in a whole new way

Featured Sales

2008 – Sold Lake Wawasee Eli Lilly Rd home for $1.425 million

2011 – Sold Highland Shores Lake Michigan home for $1.56 million

2012 – Sold Lake Maxinkuckee home for $839,000    

2012 – Sold Sevres France vase for $16,350

2012 – Sold George Jensen sterling & ivory pitcher for $10,900

2012 – Sold Thomas Gainsborough “follower” oil painting for $10,900

2014 – Sold Lake Wawasee Morrison Island home for $850,000

2014 – Sold Babe Ruth autographed baseball for $10,440

2015 – Sold Homer Davisson oil “Woman Boating” for $24,860 WORLD RECORD PRICE

2015 – Sold Homer Davisson oil “Pearson’s Mill” for $18,080 WORLD RECORD PRICE

2015 – Sold Homer Davisson art collection for $146,000 WORLD RECORD PRICE

2015 – Sold Asahel Lynde Powers “Emeline Cobb” folk art painting for $89,320

2015 – Sold Asahel Lynde Powers folk art collection for $106,140

2016 –  Sold The Amazing Fantasy #15 (CGC 7.0) for $47,560

2017 – Sold Le Pho Oil on Canvas - Parrni-Les Fleurs for $43,070

2018 – Sold 1965 Austin Healey 3000 MK III for $28,815

2018 –  Sold Lake Wawasee home for $3.5 million

2018 – Sold 1934 Graham Model 67 Convertible Coupe - AACA Presidents Cup Winner for $186,450 WORLD RECORD PRICE

2019 – Sold 1963 Tales of Suspense #39 (CGC 8.5) for $29,500

2019 – Sold 1960 Brave and the Bold #28 (CGC 8.5) for $20,650

2022 – Sold RARE LeCoultre Deep Sea Alarm automatic gentlemen's watch featuring the American Dial for $16,500

Our Sales

May 16 thru May 28
7:30pm (Thu)

Scheerer McCulloch, May16-May28_Vehicles, Comic Books, Pokémon Cards, Jewelry, Coins, Furniture Gold

Listed by Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers, Inc. Last modified 11 Days ago. 634 Pictures Total.

Fort Wayne, IN 46809
May 16 thru May 28
7:30pm (Thu)
Fort Wayne, IN 46809
May 20 thru Jun 2
12am (Mon)

Scheerer McCulloch, May 19- June 2_Antique, Rare and Vintage: Religious Items, Books, Magazines

Listed by Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers, Inc. Last modified 7 Days ago. 367 Pictures Total.

Fort Wayne, IN 46809
May 20 thru Jun 2
12am (Mon)
Fort Wayne, IN 46809
May 23 thru May 30
7:30pm (Thu)

Scheerer McCulloch, May 23-May30_Jewelry, Vintage Watches, Antiques & Collectibles, Vases

Listed by Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers, Inc. Last modified 4 Days ago. 99 Pictures Total.

Fort Wayne, IN 46809
May 23 thru May 30
7:30pm (Thu)
Fort Wayne, IN 46809

Our Testimonials

Our experience with Tim McCulloch and the rest of the staff at Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers has been nothing short of tremendously positive. They went above and beyond the call of duty in all respects. They understood our trepidation at selling our collections and antiques that we acquired over many years and became, in many respects, as “children” to us. They patiently answered questions, gave us gentle and informed assurances whenever we needed it, and did everything they possibly could to help us walk confidently through this process. In short, they overcame our apprehension with the utmost in professionalism, courtesy and patience. And the result of their leadership is evident. We broke records for auction prices on our works of art and we nearly doubled our goal for the Peabody Home Foundation’s Endowment Benefit Auction. They exceeded every expectation. We walked away from this experience with the duty to them as our new friends that we will tell of their talents to all who wish to know. So we’re telling you now: When you hire Tim McCulloch and his team, you can rest assured that your decision is the right one!Stan Williams, Director of Development, Peabody Home FoundationJanuary 2020
Hi Penny/Tim, Thank You! It was a pleasure to work with both of you including the entire staff at Scheerer McCulloch. Everyone was extremely helpful and just great to work with. Thanks!Scott and Jane McCleeryJanuary 2020
I purchased a high value item($30k) from Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers. Everyone from Tim(the owner) down to Dustin at the shipping company was easy to work with and knew their stuff. Even though I live 2,000miles away from where they're located I am thoroughly satisfied and have added their website to my bookmarks and will definitely be checking out their auctions on a regular basis. Thank you Tim and everyone at Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers! 5 stars!!Chad PfeferJanuary 2020
I was apprehensive when considering the idea of selling my house at auction. My perceptions of auctions were formed way back when I was a young girl hanging out with my dad. He'd go to an auction, usually a farm auction of someone in the community that had passed away. Dad was interested in picking up small farm implements and/or yard/garden tools. We'd even go to the "auction" barn on Saturdays to pick up the very occasional farm animal. My first bike was purchased at an auction. To me as a young girl, auctions were "lots of stuff stuffed into boxes" or "farm stuff to be purchased after someone had died." So here I am a "city gal" who has lived in the city longer than I lived in the country. No one has passed away (although after the auction signs were posted in my front yard, a few neighbors did stop by asking what had happened to me! Seems a few of them had a similar perception about auctions) and I don't have any need of farming equipment. I had lived in this house for 27 years. So why was I considering an auction?? Good question and I have a great answer! Once I met and talked with David Meyers about the benefits of selling at auction, I was all in. My older perceptions of an auction were replaced with phrases such as "the house is sold as is", "two open houses" and "on the day of the sale, it sells!" I wasn't going to have to wait months before someone would find my house acceptable to their liking. I didn't have to always have my house neat and tidy because of last minute requests to see it, and most importantly I had a definitive date that the house would sell and a definitive timeline for closing. Boom - check please! David and the team made the entire process extremely easy. No surprises. Everything was posted on an electronic bulletin board by the team members that I could access through email and see what steps were being taken day by day, week by week. I was always given advance notice of what steps I needed to take to keep the process in motion. At one of the open houses, I arrived before some of the final visitors had left. I listened to David talk very comfortably about the house details and keep them engaged and interested the entire time. That confirmed to me that he was the right man for my house. The day of the auction the setup people arrived right on time. They were respectful of the personal property as they handled it. In a very short amount of time, everything was set up and the yard looked like a party was about to take place. The auctioneer introduced himself and then it was "show time." Watching the auction was like watching a dance of sorts. Everyone on the team had a role - some were leaders and others were followers. All I did was stand back and let them do what they do best. Once the property sold, the clean up performed by the team was swift and efficient. I never once worried about any of the details of selling the place because I had complete trust in David and everyone on the team. I would definitely recommend this auction company and its team to anyone who is considering selling their home.Mona WillJanuary 2020
Dear Dave Meyers, Thank you for all you have done for me. Selling my house went so smooth and at a great price. You and your company go the extra mileRobin YeeJanuary 2020
View All Testimonials

Have Feedback?

Want to let the company know how they're doing? Feel free to leave feedback!